(reply to Yann Toutain)
As you can read in conjunction with my article critical of the events held in Tunisia, dated January 19, Yanick Toutain, I do not know personally and who has the air of being quite a stirrer of the net, to manifest his displeasure against me, while on many points we seem to agree (on the humbug of anarchist terrorism, the neo-Stalinism of the trotskiens Bensaid and Besancenot, the bourgeoisie of diplomas, etc.).. He accused me of contempt with respect to the Tunisian people and to have any proposal for the irony. First I deeply respect the Tunisian people and then I do not deny not having all the answers, as I do not pretend to be a party all by myself, even if, alas, as Mirabeau, I play still a bit this role over the medium maximalist unable to support themselves and take a position in a timely manner on major world events, while the internet system permits on five continents. Without doubt the bureaucratic system of cults always prevent rapid decisions and especially to take risks to its members coward hiding behind a comfortable anonymity. I would not answer in detail to designs Yanick unbridled libertarian, although I like his liveliness and his anti-conformist, sometimes creative but often, unfortunately, far-fetched. It has a limited grasp of history maximalist movement by taxing Ben Ali of "social-fascist" epithet that feels spongy and mothballs. I do not know what it means to his notion of "formoisy" but I know he delights, as the bourgeois press at the moment, comparisons risky and unlikely with so-called French Revolution, that is, though one may say of Rousseau's most beautiful water ... simplistic egalitarian, a foul-mouthed third-world "Africans must make half of our GDP" !!?), ignore the proletariat as a revolutionary force, and plate that the system of representation that was one of the Russian soviets of 1917 "people," the Tunisian "so idealistic and unrealistic movement in the Maghreb which we do not yet know all the ins and outs. Without customizing my reply, I will try to analyze the reality of the situation in Tunisia and more a reality of the situation a bit too flowery funerals where a bit too hasty are there to prevent any real birth or rebirth of the only revolutionary class that matters. The invocation, by supporters of UGTT France and Tunisia, the ignoble union of "all decent people" is ridiculous and poisonous tactics of the Tunisian bourgeoisie, supported and advised always covertly by Top diplomats of the French kind Védrines.
The complex reasons of lack of development of the movement and the proletarian consciousness in Tunisia, closely related to the lack of economic and civil development of this country semi-colonial (most bosses are still French), demand from the maximalist scholars and men of action of the common council a shorter rainfall laudatory study of leftist unionists limited to economic demands. But we can make a few observations, however, not so much on recent events that hinder the development of genuine revolutionary positions on the inadequacy and falsity of the methods adopted by all the excitement sermonizers leftists.
The remainders of the colonial regime, the weak development of heavy industry, the importance and the number of small business subcontracting and wages in the "tourist factory", the immense problems posed by immigration, lack of opportunities for highly educated youth and other non-graduate, all these historical facts -social deserve a very precise analysis of the maximalist view. And the inability of the proletarians of the countries left on the roadside by the uneven development of capitalism, to make up the wage level of the aristocracy western union. And ethnographic factors and their impact on the psychology of the Tunisian people characterized by a survival of individualism, lack of initiative and association by those who claim not to work for socialism in these areas but for national reconciliation and criminal.
One fact that must be highlighted is the total lack of intellectual and political ruling classes, the low level of their culture, their misogyny, their conformism and laziness tackle serious social problems. The average intellectual of the Tunisian bourgeoisie is rather low level of the shopkeeper, and it will never advance the social problem to a national solution, wrapped in cloth red star of the lantern room. His current political representation, as the dullard Ben Ali, is colorless and unconscious, it is the aggregate of any ministerial Western government, it does not care to press the rich class (see the excellent Tunisian joke is all the rage: "Ali is gone but the 40 thieves remained!) because his ministers" of national unanimity "does not care to sing the" newfound freedom "than to parade in front of the TV Western and Eastern. This is not the bourgeoisie and the proletariat Tunisian youth are educated or not expect any improvements jasmine.
And just advice states French, American, Iranian or Libyan, all run by capitalist oligarchy, religious and military, who will never accept a social protest of this magnitude, with organizations in asserting class , serve as an example to demonstrate the decay of all these schemes complicity against the universal proletariat.
The reasons are clear. On the one hand, and fundamentally, the systemic crisis kills any illusion about the natural market for consumption and output of mass unemployment. On the other hand, development of proletarian organizations out of union activists and co cops former governing party, could only harm the fable of the elections rescheduled to six months to promote the little arrangements between ex-Benali and oppositional careerists, and remount the Islamist opposition ad hoc. Although awkwardly posed and off the field by proletarian Yanick Toutain (he was the one and he deserves it), the question of the formalization of the organization - and as a mass political party independent of the bourgeoisie - is the task of Time to stop this spectacle of a nation reduced to mere sporadic demonstrations, to confabulations and coffee at the whim of fashion voyeur "twitter." A corresponding development, the political field, more than 68 in France, the working masses, would cut some of the closest media hoaxers "democratic" and soporific.
Need we remind that the Islamists, less demonized by the media that Ben Ali, smiles are the "electoral process", that pale Tunisian ruling classes have given new street imams while pretending to still be in the future dam musulmaniaques?
It is not this cowardly bourgeoisie conciliatory and that the opposition will the presence of Islamist totalitarian demos before, but only of the revolutionary pressure of the working masses.
But we must not hide if the Tunisian ruling classes are very backward, the proletariat itself has profound and severe limitations that reduce and delay the effectiveness of its action. The petty bourgeoisie
graduate, with which it is bound by a thousand ties of family relations, constitutes a real obstacle for the proletarian movement with his youthful hope of recovery of qualifications for "frame" the proletariat.
In these circumstances it is natural that the bourgeois propaganda for the "revival" meeting support among youth. The tactic established by the old rulers' follow, we examine some aspects contributes fully to prevent awareness of the impotence of the system to integrate a growing mass of unemployed, graduate or not, and promises some accommodations fictitious doomed naturally replenish Islamism which is committed to Allah to intervene to seek extensions of capitalism.
We refer to the "financial scandal" clan Ben Ali and his bitch, that fills all the columns in the Western press, which is presented as an urgent problem to repatriate wealth extradited to Tunisia. For stupidity and corruption, the system continues to post benali makeup the same way to work with the same kitchen "Republican" and even the bloody police. This habit of continually bring to the forefront the many examples of scandal profits clan nepotism Ben Ali opens the door to the option "moral" Islamist, more able to accept frugality, deprivation and punishment capitalism impoverishing the beautiful words of the old libertarian government. The limited achievement of social and wage "transition government" will naturally caused another discontent among the masses, to be skillfully exploited by parties musulmaniaques.
Ex-members of the RCD who are elected to the transitional government as they were still creatures of this oligarchic party want to take them for ratatouille couscous. They want to continue to leave the country in the hands of the bourgeoisie with the agreement of the Islamic clergy said soft. Opponents, who are basically no less reactionary, populist positions are "democratic" catch-all, proclaim themselves champions of the new freedom flowered and morals of free trade, trying to take some anti-Islamic positions and each is present in a disorganized as in France for the presidential bobble.
both sides of the Mediterranean, the workers know that when such opposition come to power, they generally become more corrupt and conservative than others. Every proletarian Tunisian immigrant who knows France knows that this description is not exaggerated. Ah, Western democracy!
The tragic mistake of the proletarians of Tunisians would be drawn into the orbit of this transition, this pseudo-democracy without a program. Mediated and dubbed by the media, cajoled by small political sects bourgeois opposition in the feverish expectation of a ministerial post, should not that the Tunisian people again the weakness of raven and the fox, he believes the pretext to gain greater freedom of movement, that the "new government" will remain neutral during the economic conflicts with the working class, albeit with some temporary improvements to taxation.
compressions to admire himself, absorbed in an exhausting work of preparing electoral base scandal, slander and strife; concerned about is to prove that the clan robbing Ben Ali public money - which would have been the only motivation of riots by the Western press complicit - lulled by promises of some electoral seats in the municipal and provincial councils, after the presidential election, for some of his children overqualified, the Tunisian people is already the butt of the joke.
Certainly, this is not universal. Both China and Algeria, occur every day strikes outside the scope of cretinism electoral struggles ultimately will awaken the spirit of proletarian revolutionaries. Tunisia unionism emerged in response. But even their union Basic anarchists who plan leaves most collaborationist leaders, fall into the easy embrace of a democracy of four cents.
And there are still those who have the nerve to take the argument of the special conditions of transient Tunisia against the Islamic threat yet fictitious and romantic!
They say that if the country is still in an uncertain time, they must denounce the "empty chair policy", an alliance even with the nephew of Ben Ali's family or the devil himself to save the population Islamists.
But if the policy of "transitional government" were to prevail, it would be even more harmful for the country where the working class believes in free elections Tunisian lawyers and citizens of autarkic national solutions.
Better abstention, to make a work-cons propaganda among the masses who want to take their destiny in order to confront and bourgeois factions to serve the West and the Islamic fractions backward.
Better to have two workers in an assembly to recognize districts that graduates twenty deputies serving a bourgeois parliamentary majority. The consequences of
siren songs on the alleged "jasmine revolution" are now fatal. Tunisian journalists and French are just walking in search of past scandals, or worse, to seek ways to bring fortunes in Switzerland or in Greenland. No newspaper involves capitalism in its Western and Eastern versions nor lets in serious political discussions among the Tunisian masses.
We do not claim to change program of society, but it causes a handful of nepotism fleeing by threatening to produce criminal records. The Tunisian and international proletariat who attends all of this may well be weary, to distrust and to scroll if discredited election comedy even in Côte d'Ivoire.
Tunisian Workers, there is only one way. Start over. Let the fantasies about the Islamic threat, the leaven of false unanimity, giving free rein to our principles of propaganda. Thieves or honest, the citizens are equal for all of us. Already more than they fear the spread of your insubordination in France than in Morocco or Algeria. Bourgeois dictators in Iran have sent the army to university. Only allow more distortion of the concept of revolution in a dubious crusade for respect for codes of the bourgeois state. Adopt a tactic ultra-intransigent proletarian class and we give an example to the world.
Only when we have awakened the sleeping lion in us, exploited class universal, we can run against the national bourgeoisie of all parties that rely both on the servility of people unhappy. Forward against the advocates of capitalism and a little more for the maximalist revolutionary.
0 comments:
Post a Comment